Norman Mailer: Works and Days

The Best Man, 1964: To Pick Him, We Must Choose between Nostalgic Extremism and Overwhelming Moderation

Mailer's review of Lyndon B. Johnson's My Hope for America, published two days before the 3 November 1964 presidential election. The second half of the review's title is most likely the work of the editors of Book Week, according to Mailer. Reprinted in 65.14 (partial), Cannibals and Christians (66.11), The Idol and the Octopus (68.11), and 98.7.

“The Best Man, 1964: To Pick Him, We Must Choose between Nostalgic Extremism and Overwhelming Moderation.” Book Week (New York Herald Tribune), 1 November 1964, 1, 7–8. Review of My Hope for America, by Lyndon B. Johnson (Random House, 1964).

The piece appears two days before the 3 November 1964 presidential election between Johnson and Barry Goldwater — the election Johnson would win in the largest popular-vote landslide in American history (61.1% to 38.5%). The “nostalgic extremism” of the subtitle is Goldwater; the “overwhelming moderation” is Johnson. The second half of the review’s title is most likely the work of the editors of Book Week, according to Mailer.

Rpt: 65.14 (partial), Cannibals and Christians (66.11), The Idol and the Octopus (68.11), 98.7.

First published: 1964-11-01
Form: criticism
Lennon & Lennon: 64.21
Cite as: /works/1964-11-01-best-man-1964
Last updated: 2026-05-27